Insights

INTERNATIONAL TAX

Foreign withholding taxes on tax‑exempt participation income

A decision of the Federal Finance Court (Bundesfinanzgericht, BFG) again shows that double‑taxation agreements can avoid legal double taxation (the same income for the same person) but not economic double taxation (the same income for a different person).

A double‑taxation agreement (DBA) regulates which of two states may apply its domestic tax law, i.e. ultimately tax the income of a person, and which state must wholly or partially waive its taxation. The aim is a single taxation of income.
The Federal Finance Court (BFG) had to decide in a case whether a credit for foreign withholding taxes could be applied against the intermediate tax or corporation tax of a private foundation.

Sachverhalt

In the present case the appellant, an Austrian private foundation, earned income from foreign shareholdings. In line with the applicable DBA, withholding tax was deducted, the DBA providing a credit method to avoid a double tax burden. Under the credit method, such withholding tax can be credited against the national corporation‑tax liability. However, a credit is only possible up to the amount of Austrian tax attributable to the foreign income.

In the present case, however, the participation income was tax‑exempt under Austrian law. The tax office therefore set the maximum credit amount at EUR 0.00. The private foundation lodged an appeal against the tax‑office decision with the BFG, seeking a credit of the withholding tax against the corporation tax (intermediate tax) or a credit against a later capital‑gains tax at the level of the foundation’s beneficiaries.

Decision of the BFG

The BFG initially affirmed, with reference to the relevant Administrative Court of the Republic of Austria (VwGH) case law, the theoretical possibility of crediting a withholding tax against the intermediate tax of a private foundation. However, if the made contributions can be deducted from the intermediate tax and this leads to the elimination of the intermediate taxation, the credit of foreign withholding taxes is no longer possible according to the VwGH. The same must, the BFG held, apply when tax‑exempt income is earned.

Union law does not conflict with the decision, as the European Court of Justice has already recognised in comparable cases that there is no breach of EU law. The question of a possible credit against a later capital‑gains tax liability was not considered decisive by the BFG. That question is to be resolved not in the corporation‑tax proceedings of the private foundation but rather in the income‑tax proceedings of the respective beneficiaries. Nevertheless, the BFG noted that such a credit (unlike in corporation tax) is not provided for in legislation at all.

Newsletter

Tax news once a month

New articles on tax, business and law arrive by e-mail once a month. You can unsubscribe at any time.